Peanut Butter Pie: First Attempt.
I have Aunt Kay’s recipe and she would never lead me astray. I followed all the directions up to the part where it says, refrigerate. That’s when I decided it was time for a taste test. Not bad. It seems to have satisfied the craving. Lookit me! Cookin’ and stuff. I had a slice of pie, but my slice was more like a blob of pie.
Browse Listings
Recently Sold

May. 19, 2026
SALE AGREED! 3658 LAUDERDALE DRIVE, TOLEDO OH 43615

Apr. 28, 2026
SOLD $17,000 ABOVE LIST PRICE! 5439 Ketukkee Trail, Toledo OH 43611

Apr. 12, 2026
SOLD $20,000 ABOVE LIST PRICE! 622 CRYSTAL LAKE, HOLLAND OH 43528

Mar. 11, 2026
SOLD OVER $10K ABOVE LIST! 1732 Wildwood Road, Toledo, OH 43614

Dec. 09, 2025
SOLD $20K ABOVE LIST PRICE! 2513 Portsmouth Avenue, Toledo, OH 43613

Nov. 11, 2025
SOLD! 8917 Creekdale Road, Sylvania, OH 43560

Nov. 06, 2025
SOLD! 2724 Latonia Boulevard, Toledo, OH 43606

Nov. 06, 2025
SOLD! 542 Eleanor Avenue, Toledo OH 43612

Nov. 06, 2025
SOLD $10K ABOVE LIST PRICE! 569 Apple Avenue, Toledo, OH 43609

Oct. 25, 2025






